These chapters on classroom rules really provided a lot of clarity for me. I was really concerned that the “autocratic” approach was the only way to maintain order in my classroom, since the “permissive” approach I am currently seeing is clearly not effective. In reality, I believe I am seeing a combination of both, which is “even worse,” according to the text.
I really believe that this approach could work SO well. The first two chapters and the introduction provided a good background for me and helped me feel like I wasn’t alone in thinking that mass chaos isn’t conducive to learning. I loved how the text discusses appropriate rules and ways to “discuss” them together per grade level. The narratives were helpful. The pictures of the bulletin boards were so helpful to me! I can truly see myself having my first graders illustrate their hopes and dreams and using these to create a few “rules” and expectations.
I really appreciated the list on pg. 53 of procedures that should be “modeled.” These concrete examples are so, so helpful as a “new” teacher.
In the second chapter, I loved how they discussed the differences between reinforcing, reminding, and redirecting language. I feel newly empowered to be direct without passing judgement. This is a skill I am eager to practice! I often feel like students won’t understand or respond unless I accompany my instructions with a question, angry stare, or other nonverbal cue. However, imagine if I only said what I meant, never passed judgement on the student but rather the behavior, and they all knew it?
It would be amazing!